IAHN
Editor-in-Chief: Janusz Ostrowski
Deputy Editor-in-Chief: Davide Viggiano
Editors: Maria Kalientzidou, Guido Gembillo
IAHN Bulletin is the official E-Newsletter of the International Association for the History of Nephrology
INTRODUCTION
It
was
in
November
2018,
one
year
after
the
10th
IAHN
Congress
in
Wieniec-Zdrój,
when
I
organised
the
IAHN
Board
meeting
in
Warsaw
and
Włocławek,
Poland.
Apart
from
myself,
it
was
kindly
attended
by
Natale
G.
De
Santo,
Katka
Derzsiova,
Iwannis
Stefanidis,
Ahmet
Aciduman
and
Bolesław
Rutkowski
as
a
special
guest
supporting
the
activities
of
the
Association.
Not
only
did
we
discuss
all
the
issues
concerning
the
IAHN
at
the
time
but
also,
in
response
to
Natale
De
Santo’s
request,
I
presented
the
initial
version
of
the
IAHN
Bulletin.
Consequently,
I
became
the
Bulletin’s
editor-in-chief,
and
the
first
official
issue
of
the
Newsletter
was
out
in
December
later
that
year.
Ever
since
then,
the
publication
has
been
prepared
and
published
biannually
on
the
official
IAHN
online
service
in
the
form
of
a
link
and
a
pdf
file.
The
Bulletin
was
also
to
be
found
on
the
ERA-EDTA
website,
and
now,
thanks
to
my
efforts,
also
on
the
webpage
of
ERA.
With
this
10th
issue
I
would
like
to
thank
everyone
whose
effort
and
engagement
have
made
it
possible
to
continue
the
publishing
of
the
Bulletin
over
the
last
5
years,
not
least
Natale
De
Santo,
the
father
and
the
good
spirit
of
this
newsletter
which
brings
information
about
the
IAHN
to
a
wide
group
of
nephrologists
around
the
world and whose impact on the life of the Association seems indisputable.
This
issue
is
dedicated
to
the
co-founder
of
the
IAHN,
the
legend
of
world
nephrology,
Professor
Shaul
Massry,
who
sadly
passed
away
on
11th
April
earlier
this
year.
We
are
glad
to
present
several
publications
about
his
life
and
achievements,
presented
by
people
who
maintained
particularly
close
contacts
with
him,
by
friends
from
around
the
world. A great man, a giant in the field of medicine, especially nephrology, our friend has left us.
I
hope
that
the
readers
of
our
Bulletin,
IAHN
members
and
our
supporters
will
find
this
issue
interesting.
After
5
years
of
managing
the
Bulletin
and
gaining
experience
I
am
fully
aware
that
it
may
be
time
to
change
its
form
to
make
its
content more attractive and interesting.
I wish all of you and all our friends a good holiday time and rest after all year’s hard work.
Janusz Ostrowski
Editor-in-Chief
Bulletin
No. 10, June 2023
www.iahn.info
Janusz Ostrowski
Professor,
Centre of Postgraduate
Medical Education,
Warsaw, Poland
janusz.ostrowski@cmkp.edu.pl
Board of the International Association for the History of Nephrology
Ayse Balat – President
Iwannis Stefanidis – Past President
Davide Viggiano – President Elect
Vincenzo Savica – Treasurer
Natale G. De Santo - (ex officio)
Councillors:
In
line
with
his
commitment
to
education,
Shaul
created
several
forums
to
communicate,
share,
and
stimulate
medical
research
worldwide.
To
this
end
he
organized
medical
symposia
and
conferences
across
the
world,
especially
in
developing
countries,
where
local
nephrologists
were
provided
with
exposure
to
leading
scientists
in
the
field.
His
attention
to
the
details
of
assuring
the
success
of
those
meetings
are
legend.
He
devoted
as
much
time
to
organizing
the
scientific
programs
as
he
did
to
the
festivities
surrounding
them,
be
they
that
of
honoring
a
regional
cultural
eminence,
celebrating
the
achievements
of
an
up-coming
local
investigator,
or
acknowledging
the
contributions
of
the
hosting
institution.
No
to
forget
the
memorable
farewell
dinners
that
he
so
much
delighted in orchestrating. Nobody else could put on an educational program like those Shaul did.
In
line
with
his
commitment
to
the
biomedical
sciences,
Shaul
created
the
Meira
and
Shaul
G.
Massry
Foundation
in
1995.
Since
1996,
the
Foundation
has
granted
the
Annual
Massry
Prize
which
is
awarded
to
investigators
who
have
made
fundamental
contributions
to
the
biomedical
sciences.
The
prize
consists
of
a
Massry
gold
medal,
a
gothic-style
colorful
certificate
printed
on
parchment
paper,
and
a
substantial
monetary
award.
The
impact
of
these
prizes
can
be
ascertained
from
the
fact
that
they
have
come
to
be
recognized
and
coveted
worldwide
as
a
prestigious
award
of
which
over
half
of
its
past
recipients
have
gone
on
to
become
Nobel
Laureates
in
Chemistry
or
in
Physiology
and
Medicine.
Having
served
as
the
master
of
ceremonies
at
most
of
those
Award
sessions
for
the
past
26
years,
I
can
attest
to
the
pride
and
delight
that
Shaul
derived
as
he
personally
awarded
the
prize
to
each
recipient.
The
Massry
Foundation
also
sponsors
an
annual
visiting
professorship
to
the
two
medical
schools
in
Los
Angeles
(USC,
UCLA)
and
provides
research
support
for
medical students at the University of California Keck Medical School.
Shaul
was
a
big
deal.
Not
just
because
of
his
accomplishments,
awards,
accolades,
and
recognitions,
but
also
because
of
his
enormous
generosity
and
immense
concern
for
the
well-being
of
others.
Yes,
he
could
be
stubborn
and
opinionated
but
his
affable
character,
infectious
enthusiasm,
and
devotion
to
friends
were
unique.
In
the
course
of
his
life,
either
directly
or
indirectly,
he
touched
the
lives
of
an
innumerable
number
of
people
because
of
his
genuine
care
and
empathy
for
the
welfare
of
others.
Anyone
who
ever
sat
across
from
him
walked
away
feeling
like
they
mattered,
had
a
mission
to
accomplish,
and
usually
formed
a
strong
and
enduring
relationship
with
him.
He
in
turn
enjoyed
their
company
and
delighted
in
their
accomplishments.
One
of
his
sayings
was,
“Life
is
good,
and
friends
are
its
perfume.”
He
meant
it
and
he
lived
it
every
day
of
his
life.
Critically,
Shaul
had
an
unusual
knack
for
recognizing
talent
in
others
and
nurturing
it
–
something
he
seems
to
have
acquired
from
the
hardships
he
had
to
overcome
in
his
own
life
of
growing
up
as
a
Jew
in
Iraq, of doing research in the isolated and scorching heat of the Negev desert in Israel, and of thriving in the competitive environment of American research.
I
was
a
beneficiary
of
this
latter
aspect
of
Shaul.
We
met
in
the
late
1960s
and
immediately
bonded.
Over
the
years
he
mentored
me,
advised
me,
guided
me,
comforted
me,
promoted
me,
and
literally
became
an
integral
part
of
my
life.
He
was
the
knight
in
shining
armor
on
a
white
charger
anyone
would
wish
for
by
his
side
through
the
trials
and
tribulations
of
life.
We
used
to
coordinate
our
travels
to
meetings
in
order
to
have
time
to
talk,
discuss
and
commensurate
together.
As
we
aged
and
those
opportunities
diminished
we
used
to
have
30
minutes
or
longer
talks
on
the
phone
at
least
once
or
twice
a
month.
We
last
talked,
albeit
briefly,
ten
days
before
he
passed
away.
With
his
passing,
I
have
lost
the
spiritual
older
brother
that
I
was
so
lucky
to
relish
for
the
past
50
years of my life.
Figure 1b. Shaul Massry's Solemn Pledge
on the Symbol of the University
Figure 1a. Shaul Massry delivers the doctoral lecture - Gratitude (Gratiarum Actio),
before the ceremonial session of the UPJŠ Academic Board
Figure 1d. Professor Shaul Massry and his wife Meira
Figure 1c. Program of the International Symposium "Metabolic changes
in chronic renal failure" on the occasion of the awarding
of the honorary degree Dr.h.c. to Professor Shaul Massry
Garabed Eknoyan,
Distinguished Emeritus
Professor of Medicine,
Baylor College of Medicine,
Houston, Texas.
OBITUARIES
SHAUL G. MASSRY, THE BROTHER I ONCE HAD.
Shaul
G.
Massry
(1930-2023)
one
of
the
founding
fathers
of
nephrology
died
on
April
11,
2023.
He
was
92
years
old.
Shaul
achieved
prominence
in
the
formative
years
of
nephrology
and
as
a
second-generation
nephrologist,
trained
by
two
of
the
founders
of
the
discipline
(George
E.
Schreiner,
Charles
R.
Kleeman),
he
was
instrumental
in
the
establishment,
development,
growth
and
evolution
of
nephrology.
With
Shaul’s
passing
away
the
world
of
nephrology
has lost one of its legendary giants, visionary leaders, and creative contributors. ( Fig. 1)
For
25
years
(1974-1999)
Shaul
served
as
Chief
of
Nephrology
at
the
University
of
Southern
California
(USC)
Keck
School
of
Medicine.
His
ground
breaking
research
focused
on
uremic
toxicity
and
specifically
established
the
detrimental
systemic
effects
of
parathyroid
hormone
changes
in
the
course
of
progressive
kidney
disease.
During
this
period
the
USC
division
of
nephrology
became
one
of
the
foremost
world
centers
of
clinical
and
scientific
excellence
in
renal
studies
that
attracted
and
trained
some
150
fellows,
several
of
whom
now
serve
as
chiefs
or
members
of
academic nephrology sections worldwide.
As
a
scientist
of
limitless
energy,
immense
creativity,
and
boundless
inquisitiveness,
over
the
60
years
of
his
academic
career,
Shaul
published
some
800
scientific
papers,
and
authored
or
co-edited
over
30
symposia
and
books.
In
addition,
he
established
two
medical
journals,
one
of
which
the
American
Journal
of
Nephrology
is
now
in
its
53rd
year
of
publication.
He
also
co-edited
the
Textbook
of
Nephrology
with
Richard
J.
Glassock
in
1983,
Therapy
of
Renal
Diseases
with
Wadi
N.
Suki
in
1984,
and
Nutritional
Management
of
Renal
Disease
with
Joel
D.
Kopple
in
2003.
As
a
result
of
his
contributions
to
medical
knowledge,
Shaul
was
awarded
14
honorary
doctorate
degrees
from
universities
across
Europe,
membership
in
11
medical
societies
across
the
world,
7
elections
to
foreign
Academies
of
Science,
and
innumerable
recognitions
and
prizes
by
scientific
and
professional
societies.
In
addition,
he
served
in
a
leading
role
and
president
of
a
dozen
foundations
and
medical
societies,
notably
that
of
our
own
International
Association
for
the
History of Nephrology (IAHN) which he helped establish in 1974.
Introduction
Shaul
Massry,
our
beloved
Friend,
has
passed.
The
long
stride
from
the
Jewish
Community
(with
no
political
clout)
of
Basra
to
Beverly
Hills,
has
come
to
an
end.
In
Basra
he
was
recognized
as
the
best
student
at
his
high
school
and
at
the
univerdity.
Shaul
Massry
died
a
righteous
man,
who,
as
a
wise
physician
and
professor
of
medicine,
campaigned
for
palliative
care,
humane
care.
In
paraphrasing
Italo
Calvino,
“he
was
a
classic,
who
never
stopped
to
say
what
had
to say” (1).
Having
achieved
all
his
familial,
cultural
and
scientific
goals,
he
was
spiritually
ready
to
go.
He
engaged
till
the
end
with
family
and
remained
connected
with
his
most
dearest
students
and
friends.
He
died
proud
of
his
more
than
one
hundred and fifty fellowships from all over the world and for many more achievements.
The birth of the International Association for the History of Nephrology
The
International
Association
for
the
History
of
Nephrology
(IAHN),
as
many
good
things,
was
created
by
necessity
with
the
aim
“to
give
voice
to
the
many
dormant
historians
of
nephrology
awaiting
an
opportunity
to
come
out
of
the
closet.
Natale
Gaspare
De
Santo,
Garabed
Eknoyan
and
Shaul
G.
Massry,
while
travelling
in
Poland
on
a
bus
from
Lublin
to
Poznan
for
an
international
event
organized
by
Professor
Kazimierz
Bączyk
in
1992,
gave
birth
to
IAHN.
It
was
then
that
the
goal
of
the
society
was
identified,
a
list
of
dormant
historians
of
nephrology
identified,
and
the
structure
of
the
association
shaped.
It
was
decided
to
start
with
a
preparatory
conference
in
Italy
which
took
place
on
October
28-30,
1993,
between
Naples
and
Montecassino
(Fig.
1
and
2).
The
conference
was
promoted
by
the
Second
University
of
Naples
(President
Domenico
Mancino),
the
Italian
Institute
for
Philosophical
Studies
(President,
Avvocato
Gerardo
Marotta),
Baylor
College
of
Medicine
(President,
William
T.
Butler),
and
The
Benedictine
Abbey
of
Montecassino
(Abbot
Bernardo
D’Onorio)”(2).
More
than
80
putative
historians
attended
the
meeting.
The
list
of
speakers
included:
N.
G.
De
Santo,
G.
Eknoyan,
S.
Massry,
L.
Iorio,
S.G.
Marketos,
C.W.
Gottschalk,
S.
Sabatini,
E.
Kinne-Saffran,
N.A.
Kurtzman,
A.D
‘Angelo,
S.
Favaro,
G.
Aliotta,
B.
Cavarra,
G.
Federspill,
A.
Tizianello,
F.
Rossi,
M.
Timio,
F.F.
Avagliano,
M.D.M.
Tortora,
J.C.M.
Chan,
R.J.
Petrucelli,.R.
Palmero,
J.S.
Cameron;.
J.D.Kopple,
T.
Fogazzi,
E.
Ritz,
M.
Cirillo,
V.
Bonomini,
G.
Conte,
K.
Hierholzer,
L.
Calò,
R.
A.
Bernabeo,
R.K.H.
Kinne,
L.
Fine,
S.
Musitelli,
M.
Oldoni,
M.
Pasca,
R.L.
Chevalier,
A.
Borsatti,
L.
Melillo,
A.
Heidland,
B.
Cavarra,
F.P.
Schena, G. Chieffi. M.U. Dianzani, and L. R. Angeletti, G. Capasso and H. Iahn.
Natale Gaspare De Santo,
Emeritus Professor University
Luigi Vanvitelli Naples
SHAUL
MASSRY,
A
CLASSIC
THAT
NEVER
STOPPED
TO
SAY
WHAT
HE
HAD
TO
SAY
-
OUR
FRIEND
HAS
GONE
Luigi Iorio,
Former Director Division
of Medicine and Nephrology,
Cassino Hospital,
Cassino Italy
The
Day
in
Cassino
was
organized
by
Luigi
Iorio,
Chief
of
the
Division
of
Nephrology
at
De
Bonis
Hospital
in
Cassino
and
by
Bernardo
D’Onorio,
the
Abbot
of
the
Abbey.
For
the
event
the
late
Father
Faustino
Avagliano,
Director
of
the
Montecassino
Archives,
organized
an
exhibit
of
nine
Codices
of
the
Art
of
Medicine
and
prepared
a
catalogue
in
Latin
(Fig.
3).
The
Institute
of
Botanics
of
the
University
of
Naples
organized
in
the
Cloister
of
Abbey
an
exhibition
of
Diuretic
Plants
described
by
Dioscorides
(Fig.
4),
and
an
exhibit
of
some
Antique
books
on
Italian
herbals
in
the
hall
of
the
Italian
Institute
for
Philosophical Studies.
A
detailed
account
is
described
in
American
Journal
of
Nephrology
1994
as
a
prologue
to
the
Proceedings
of
the
event.
A
business
meeting
was
held
at
the
conclusion of the conference, where it was voted to establish the International Association for the History of Nephrology (2).
It
is
appropriate
to
remember
that
Shaul
Massry
was
Editor
in
Chief
of
the
Journal
and
he
had
enrolled
Garabed
Eknoyan
to
serve
as
Sectional
Editor
for
the
History
of
Nephrology
(the
first
editor
for
history
of
our
discipline).
In
the
subsequent
30
years
IAHN
celebrated
12
congresses
and
published
nearly
450
papers
in
American
Journal
of
Nephrology,
Journal
of
Nephrology,
Giornale
Italiano
di
Nefrologia
Hellenic
Archives
of
Medicine
,
Experimental
and
Clinical Transplantation
, listed on the website. In addition printed books have been published for congresses nos.1-10, as reported in IAHN’s website.
Places of the soul visited with Shaul Massry
For
nearly
40
years
we
met
with
Shaul
Massry
not
only
in
historical
congresses,
but
at
more
than
50
international
events
around
the
world.
The
group
traditionally
dined
together
in
the
evening
and
keep
late
hours
chatting
about
our
families
and
programs.
These
were
occasions
to
visit
museums,
cultural
landmarks,
concerts
where
we
enjoyed
each
other’s
company.
A
total
of
11
places
of
the
soul
are
listed
in
Table
1.
They
come
to
my
mind
as
the
great
possibility for scientists to exchange science, but also to share unforgettable cultural events.
Such
satellite
events
are
very
important
for
scientists
since
they
help
to
put
their
work,
what
belongs
to
the
disciplines
they
practice,
into
the
appropriate
cultural
context.
In
addition,
they
help
to
becalm
the
anxiety
of
people
looking
for
what
comes
next.
In
this
context,
concerts
have
a
poignant
role.
In
fact,
music
is
full
of
meaning.
As
George
Steiner
wrote:
“…
it
is
the
most
significant
human
event
that
can
communicate
the
nearing
of
the
transcendent,
a
therapy
for
the
wounds
of
the
spirit”.
As
Nietzsche
says
it
is
“mysteriumtremendum”
to
be
necessarily
included
in
a
modern
“quadrivium”
along
with
mathematics, architecture and biogenetics(3).
With
Massry,
we
had
special
antiquity
shops
to
visit
in
Naples,
Taormina,
Kosice,
Cassino.
Shaul
looked
for
local
imitation
of
Fabergé
eggs
(1885-1915),
XVI-XVII
century
bibles,
and
XVII-XVIII
century
furniture.
Luigi
Iorio
loved
the
functionality
of
the
desks
in
style
Louis
Philippe(1830-1848),
De
Santo
looked
for
1st
edition
postwar
Italian
literary
books
(a
sustainable
hobby),
bells
and
first
half
20th
century
minor
painters
(to
learn),
Russian
icons.
Guido
Bellinghieri
is
an
expert
of
stones
and
a
specialist
of
Sciacca
coral,
an
a
collector
of
old
medical
books,
whereas
Vincenzo
Savica
loves
modern
potteries
.We
had
our
places.
In
Kosice
it
was
on
Krmanova
Street,
site
of
the
central
Hlavnáulica,
near
the
Cathedral,
very
specialized
in
Central
Europe
painters
and
sculptors
of
the
1st
half
of
the
20th
century
.
In
Taormina
(nearly
every
time
we
met
in
Messina,
we
went
to
Taormina)
we
visited
a
fine
furniture
shop
near
Porta
Messina
and
a
shop
with
ancient
books,
maps
and
gouaches
near
Porta
Catania
along
Corso
Umberto.
In
Naples
the
Libreria
Antiquaria
Regina
on
Costantinopoli
Street,
was
and
is
the
unsurpassed
place
for
ancient
bibles
and
gouches.
In
Cassino
the
most
learned
antique
dealer
to
visit
and
talk
to
was
Mr.
Santulli
on
Arinni
Street.
His
descriptions
of
furniture
disclosed
the
talent
of
the
artisan
who
made
them
and
of
their
workshops.
Visiting
such
shops was relaxing and edifying, a way to enter the mysteries of how men and women shape the world.
Table 1. Places of the soul visited with Shaul Massry
I
.
Axelmunthe Home in Anacapri in 1977.
I
I
.
An evening concert of Severino Gazzelloni at Punta Tragara (Capri) in 1980.
I
I
I
.
An evening private visit of the Cistercian Gothic Duomo of Cosenza (1122), in 1980.
I
V
.
Discovering The Lombard Church of Santa Sofia in Benevento and the Museo del Sannio, 1980.
V
.
Verdi’
Machbeth
at
San
Carlo
Theatre
in
Naples,
Conductor
Riccardo
Muti,
Opera
Director
Roiberto
De
Simone
,
Scenography-costumes
by
Giacomo
Manzu, Renato Bruson baritone, in 1984. A Macbethh defined by specialists “with the color of the sun”.
V
I
.
A
whole
morning
visit
to
The
Seven
Works
of
Mercy
of
Caravaggio
at
Pio
Monte
della
Misericordia
in
Naples.
No
guide
but
equipped
with
expert
annotated books in 1984.
V
I
I
.
Rafting
on
the
waters
of
the
river
Dunajec
in
Tatras
Mountains
―Pieniny
National
Park―,
together
with
Garabed
Eknoyan
and
Joel
Kopple
hosted
by
Miro Mydlik, in 1996 (Fig. 5).
V
I
I
I
.
The
astonishing
one
day
tour
from
Montecassino
to
the
Abbey
of
Casamari
(Veroli,
Frosinone)
and
to
the
Cathedral
of
Alatri,
and
the
Cathedral
of
Anagni (the city of Boniface VIII) in 1998.
I
X
.
The
evening
visit
to
the
Anatomy
Theatre
of
Girolamo
Fabricid’
Acquapendente
and
a
guided
visit
to
Giotto’s
paintings
in
the
Chapel
of
Scrovegni
in
Padua, with Augusto Antonello and Lorenzo Calò, in 1998.
X
.
A whole morning at Caffè Greco in Padua 2003.
X
I
.
Walking on the banks and waters of the perennial river Alcantara (between Catania and Messina, mouth in the Ionian Sea), in 2004.
X
I
I
.
Memorial concert for Pope John Paul II in the Oliwa Cathedral of Gdansk, where 1000 artists and the the Baltic Philarmonic Orchestra played (2005).
Shaul Massry in Naples
Shaul
Massry
came
to
Naples
innumerable
times
(Table
2).
He
was
also
Visiting
Professor
of
Medicine
by
invitation
of
Professor
Carmelo
Giordano,
who
also
proposed,
as
President
of
SIN,
Shaul
Massry
as
Honorary
Member
of
the
Italian
Society
of
Nephrology.
Massry
was
the
first
non-Italian
honorary
member.
Massry
was
a
constant
presence
in
the
Capri
Conference
on
Uremia
(1974,
1977,
1980
an
1984)
and
later
of
the
Giovanni
Alfondo
Borelli
Conferences
on
Acid
Base
Balance
(1984,
1987,
1991)
organized
by
Natale
G
De
Santo,
Giovambattista
Capasso
and
Massimo
Cirillo,
7th
European
Colloquium
on
Renal
Physiology
in
Naples,in1992
that
included
an
excursion
to
Paestum
(Figure
6),
the
1996
Conference
on
Human
Clinical
Research
at
the
Italian
Institute
for
Philosophical
Studies
(4)
and
of
the
Conference
on
Edema.
Pathophysiology
and
Therapy
,
the
first
European
Master
in
Nephrological
Sciences
(Magister
Nephrologiae,
Neapoli
s,
MNN)
,
the
First
Conference
on
Survival
is
not
Enough
,
on
occasion
of
the
2007
World
Kidney
Day).
His
contributions
were
centered
on
his
favorite
topics,
namely
calcium
balance,
PTH
and
uremic
toxins.
He
very
much
supported
the
idea
behind
Survival is not Enough and he invited presentations on this topic at many international events.
All
events
in
Naples
had
the
Patronage
of
Italian
Institute
for
Philosophical
Sciences
and
the
enthusiastic
support
of
his
visionary
President
Avvocato
Gerardo
Marotta
(5).
The
books
coproduced
with
the
Institute
are
part
of
unique
catalogue
of
books
that
have
been
shown
in
at
Warbug
Institute,
and
at
the
Parliament in London at the Academy of Sciences in Moscow.
Table 2. Scientific event s in collaboration with Shaul Massry
I
.
Capri Uremia Conference 1974, 1977, 1980, and 1984 organized by Carmelo Giordano.
I
I
.
Visiting Professor Department of Medicine , 1ST Faculty of Medicine, University of Naples, 1985 (Invited by Carmelo Giordano).
I
I
I
.
Giovanni Alfonso Borelli Conference and Award on Acid Base balance 1991, 1995, 1999 (Massry was Recipient of the Medal), 2004.
I
V
.
7th European Colloquium on Renal Physiology, Naples, 1992.
V
.
An International Conference on the History of Nephrology, Naples-Montecassino , Octobe28-30, 1993.
V
I
.
8th International Congress on Nutrition and Metabolism in Renal Disease, October 9-12, 1996.
V
I
I
.
An Appeal for Clinical Research, Palazzo Serra di Cassano, September 15-1997
V
I
I
I
.
20 Years Nephrology in Cassino, 1998, taking place in the Sala capitularis of the Abbey (Fig. 7-9)
I
X
.
Master in Scienze Nefrologiche
(Magister Nephologiae, Neapolis)
, 2000-2001.
X
.
Survival is not Enough- Quality of Life
in CKD, March, March 7-8, 2007 (1st of an annual multisite conference, 2007-2020).
X
I
.
IV IAHN Congress in Montecassino, 2007.
It
is
worth
mentioning
that
we
had
outstanding
scientific
meetings
on
uremic
toxicity
with
Massry
and
particularly
enjoyed
those
in
Nagoya,
organized
by
Toshimitsu Niwa in 1999 and in Gdansk in 2005 organized by Boleslaw Rutkowski (Fig. 10, 11).
Ayse Balat, MD,
President of IAHN,
Gaziantep University,
School of Medicine,
Department of Pediatric Nephrology,
Gaziantep, Turkiye.
PROF SHAUL G. MASSRY; AN INSPIRING SCIENTIST
In
this
Bulletin,
you
will
read
much
about
Prof
Massry
from
his
close
friends.
I
am
one
of
the
luckiest
people
who
had
the
opportunity
to
get
to
know
him
closely
at
the
MKS
and
IAHN
congresses
which
he
was
one
of
the
founders
(Fig.1). Although the words cannot fully express our emotions, I tried to express my feelings below.
Imagine
a
man
who
chose
to
be
a
doctor.
He
spent
part
of
his
medical
career
in
challenging
geography
under
difficult
conditions.
He
never
gave
up
and
pursued
his
ideals
and
the
way
he
knew
right;
“he
did
everything
his
way”.
He
always
worked,
and
success
followed
him.
He
continued
to
illuminate
his
surroundings
like
an
everlasting
candle.
He
encouraged
scientists,
welcomed
students
from
all
over
the
world,
and
continued
to
educate
without
discrimination.
Prof
Massry
didn't
just
work;
“he
inspired”.
He
had
such
a
tremendous
life
experience
that
anyone
who
could
listen
to
his
conversation
at
his
desk
felt
rewarded.
I
was
one
of
those
who
had
the
chance
to
listen
to
him
and
his
speeches
at
congresses.
As
both
adult
and
pediatric
nephrologists,
we
learned
much
from
him.
His
teachings
went
beyond
the
scientific;
his
perspectives
on
social
life
were
equally
enlightening.
He
was
one
of
the
most
elegant
people
I've
ever
met,
thinking
"people
first".
He
was
the
best
answer
to
the
question
of
"how
to
be
on
the
way
of
science",
especially
the
ability
to
solve mutual communication problems.
The
loss
of
this
remarkable
scientist
will
be
deeply
felt.
He
left
indelible
memories,
from
his
significant
contributions
to
the
global
kidney
community
in
education,
investigation,
and
leadership
to
his
beautiful
messages
during
congress
dinners.
His
valuable
works
will
continue
to
guide
us,
and
his
memory
will
live
on
in
our
hearts.
We
will
always
remember him with love. May he rest in peace.
Figure 1. The 3rd Congress of Mediterranean Kidney Society - Cappadocia, Turkey -
June 10-13,2015. From Right to Left; Prof Shaul G Massry, Prof Ayse Balat
and Prof Guido Bellinghieri
Professor
Shaul
G.
Massry,
a
pioneer
in
renal
medicine
and
Professor
Emeritus
of
Medicine,
Physiology
and
Biophysics
at
the
Keck
School
of
Medicine,
University
of
Southern
California,
has
passed
away
at
the
age
of
92
in
Beverly Hills.
He
was
one
of
the
most
eminent
experimental
and
clinical
nephrologists,
recognized
not
just
in
the
U.S.
but
worldwide. He had an extremely successful career that allowed him to continue his research for over 60 years.
He
was
the
laureate
of
the
honorary
degree
of
"Doctor
Honoris
Causa"
(Dr.h.c,)
of
a
number
of
universities
in
Europe,
including Slovakia.
Professor
Shaul
Massry
was
the
first,
out
of
seven
outstanding
world
nephrologists,
to
have
been
awarded
the
honorary
degree
of
Dr.h.c.
by
Pavol
Jozef
Šafárik
University
(UPJŠ)
in
Košice
in
1993.
Until
1993,
he
visited
Košice
three
times
(1984,
1993
-
twice).
He
was
an
invited
lecturer
at
the
International
Congress
of
Nephrology
in
Košice
on
the
first
occasion.
He
visited
the
IV
Internal
Clinic
of
the
UPJŠ
Medical
Faculty
and
some
other
university
departments
during
his
stay.
He
visited
Košice
once
again
in
March
1993
and
lectured
at
the
scientific
meeting
of
the
Medical
Society
in
Košice.
He
was
a
visiting
professor
at
the
UPJŠ
Faculty
of
Medicine
from
1
to
7
November
1993
and
lectured
repeatedly
to
medical
students.
Professor
Shaul
Massry
was
awarded
the
honorary
degree
of
Doctor
Honoris
Causa
of
UPJŠ
in
Košice
on
4
November
1993.
He
received
the
award
from
the
hands
of
the
Rector
of
the
University,
Professor
RNDr.
Lev
Bukovský,
DrSc
(1),
(Fig.
1).
The
ceremony
took
place
in
the
Historical
Hall
of
the
UPJŠ
Rectorate.
The
gala
dinner
was
hosted
at
the
historic
Krásna
Hôrka
Castle.
The
following
day,
the
International
Nephrology
Symposium,
"Metabolic
Changes
in
Chronic
Renal
Failure"
was
held
at
the
East
Slovak
Gallery,
where
he
presented
his
lecture
"Uremia
is
a
state
of
Cellular
Calcium
Toxicity",
one
of
the
most
significant
studies
from
his
abundant lecturing and publishing activities.
SHAUL
MASSRY,
"DOCTOR
HONORIS
CAUSA"
OF
PAVOL
JOZEF
ŠAFÁRIK
UNIVERSITY
IN
KOŠICE,
SLOVAKIA
Shaul
Massry
repeatedly
visited
Košice
as
the
active
participant
on
the
occasion
of
awarding
the
honorary
degree
of
Dr.h.c.
to
other
distinguished
nephrologists,
Professors
Joel
Kopple
(USA,1995),
Horst
Klinkmann
(Germany,1997),
Franciszek
Kokot
(Poland,1997),
Natale
De
Santo
(Italy,1999),
and
Guido
Bellinghieri
(Italy,2000).
He
did
not
attend
the
last
conferral
of
the
honorary
degree
of
Dr.h.c.
on
Professor
Vittorio
Bonomini
(Italy)
in
2006,
for
family reasons. Professor Miroslav Mydlík, M.D., DrSc., proposed the awarding of the degree of Dr.h.c. to all seven excellent nephrologists.
His
subsequent
visits
to
Košice
were
associated
with
his
active
participation
in
the
8th
International
Nephrology
Symposium
held
on
the
occasion
of
the
life
and
professional
jubilee
of
Professor
Mydlik,
where
he
presented
his
lecture
“Abnormality
of
B-cell
function“
(2007),
(Fig.
2).
He
also
participated
in
the
9th
International
Nephrology
Symposium
organized
in
memory
of
Professor
Albert
Válek,
DrSc.,
(2009,
Tatranská
Lomnica,
the
High
Tatras),
where
he
presented
his
lecture
“Vascular
calcification
in
CKD
patients“
(2),
(Fig.
3).
Albert
Válek
was
one
of
the
founders
of
the
Czechoslovak
Nephrological
Society.
He
was
a
long-time
President
of
the
aforementioned
Society.
Professor
Albert
Válek
was
an
outstanding
nephrologist
of
European
renown,
recognized both in Europe and in the USA.
During
his
stay
in
the
High
Tatras,
Shaul
Massry
visited
the
Hrebienok
Tourist
Centre
and
the
Franz
Kafka
Memorial
in
Tatranské
Matliare,
which
was
designed
and
unveiled
by
Professor
Mydlík
(2001).
He
also
visited
the
city
of
Kežmarok.
All
international
participants,
together
with
the
organizers
of
the
symposium,
were
hosted
by
the
Mayor
of
Kežmarok,
Ing.
Igor
Šajtlava.
Professor
Massry
took
an
interest
in
the
history
of
Kežmarok,
which
was
described
to
him
by
the
Mayor
during
a
lively
conversation.
In
addition,
he
also
visited
the
Dialysis
Centre
in
Kežmarok,
Dialcorp
Ltd.,
where
Miroslav
Mydlík
had
been
a
consultant
for
many
years.
Shaul
Massry
and
Guido
Bellinghieri
spent
the
next
day
in
Košice.
The
last
evening
was
a
farewell
dinner
in
an
excellent
restaurant.
This was Professor Massry's last visit to Košice, but not our last meeting.
Shaul
Massry
had
established
the
so-called
"Massry
Group",
to
which
we
(Miro
Mydlik
and
Katka)
belonged,
which
used
to
gather
in
various
cities
in
Europe, the USA, and Asia for various international congresses, most often in Sicily, organized by Professors Guido Bellinghieri and Vincenzo Savica.
Professor
Shaul
Massry
proposed
the
"International
Distinguished
Medal
of
the
National
Kidney
Foundation"
award
to
Professor
Mydlík,
which
was
presented to him in 1994 in Orlando, the USA.
Shaul loved life, his motto was "Life is Good".
The
memory
of
Professor
Shaul
Massry
as
a
true
friend
who
loved
Slovakia,
the
High
Tatras,
and
Košice,
will
forever
remain
in
my
memory
and
in
my heart.
Fig. 1:
Professor Shaul G. Massry, "Doctor Honoris Causa" of Pavol Jozef Šafárik University in Košice
Dipl. Ing. Katarina Derzsiova
Former Head of the Nephrological Laboratory
IVth Internal Clinic
University Hospital of L. Pasteur
Košice, Slovak Republic
Figure 1e. Krásna Hôrka Castle
Figure 2b. A photograph of international participants
in the Symposium with Miro Mydlik
Figure 2a. Professor Shaul Massry and Professor Natale De Santo
congratulate Professor Miroslav Mydlík
Figure 2c. Shaul Massry giving a lecture at the Symposium
at the East Slovak Gallery in Košice.
Figure 3b. Friendly discussion with the Mayor of Kežmarok,
Ing. I. Šajtlava
Figure 3a.Visit to the Franz Kafka Memorial during the Symposium
in Tatranské Matliare, in the High Tatras
Figure 3d. Prof. Shaul Massry's last visit to Košice,
on his way back from the High Tatras in 2009,
during a farewell dinner in a restaurant
Figure 3c. Professor Shaul Massry visiting the Dialysis Centre
of Dialcorp s.r.o., in Kežmarok
Alessandra F. Perna
Professor of Nephrology,
Chief Nephrology and Dialysis Unit,
University of Campania Luigi Vanvitelli,
Naples, Italy
SHAUL MASSRY, A CHARISMATIC SCIENTIST AND A WISE MAN.
I
have
known
Shaul
Massry
since
1986,
when
he
came
as
a
visiting
scientist
at
the
Nephrology
Unit
of
the
Policlinic
in
Naples,
Italy,
at
the
invitation
of
Carmelo
Giordano,
who
was
then
Chief
of
the
Unit
at
the
University.
At
the
time
I
was
26
years
old,
and
striving
to
find
my
place
in
the
world.
As
the
daughter
of
a
well-educated
American
woman
from
New
York,
and
of
an
ambitious
University
cardiologist
and
nephrologist
from
Naples,
it
was
obvious
to
me
that
I
could
pursue
a
carrier
in
the
Accademia,
because
this
was
within
my
means,
however
difficult,
and
the
right
place
for
me.
But
it
was
understood,
and
also
prof
Natale
De
Santo
to
whom
I
looked
to
for
advice
suggested
this,
that
a
period
of
training
outside
Italy
would
have
been
auspicious
and
advisable,
and
even
necessary.
At
that
time,
Italy
was
still
very much under the cultural influence of the United States, especially regarding science.
At
this
point
prof
Shaul
Massry
came
into
my
life.
He
was
vibrant
and
charismatic,
and
definitively
this
encounter
made
a
difference
for
me.
I
asked
him
if
I
could
join
his
unit
in
Los
Angeles,
and
he
immediately
said
yes,
provided
that
I
could
join
his
unit
in
a
short
time.
So,
in
August
1987
I
started
working
with
him
at
the
University
of
Southern
California, Los Angeles, and remained there for three years.
He
was
very
enthusiastic
and
passionate
about
his
work
as
a
scientist,
devoted
to
the
study
of
uremic
toxins,
and
especially
parathyroid
hormone.
In
his
laboratory,
parathyroid
hormone
was
studied
in
humans
and
in
a
rat
model
of
chronic
kidney
disease
under
various
respects,
for
example
anemia,
bone
disease,
red
cell
function,
etc
were
examined.
At
some
point,
during
the
years,
I
perceived
he
was
even
mocked
by
some
unkind
fellow
colleagues
because
what
was
thought
as
a
“fixation”
on
parathyroid
hormone
studies;
but
we
know
today
that
this
is
the
only
way
that
a
field
can
be
pushed
forward.
In
other
words,
only
relentlessly
pursuing
an
idea
can
put
studies
on
a
given
topic
into
fast
forward
and
into
fruition.
He
was
so
energetic
and
animated
about
PTH
that
even
his
car
had
a
PTH
plate
!
Of
course,
in
California
custom
plates
are
common.
Indeed,
the
field
of
uremic
toxicity
was
slowly
expanding,
and
many
original
aspects
regarding
toxins
and
new
toxins
were
discovered
since
then.
I
myself
continued
into
the
field,
and
I
later
on
in
life
studied
other
uremic
toxins,
such
as
homocysteine,
and
uncovered
the
role
of
a
new
uremic
toxin,
lanthionine,
in
a
life
long
collaboration
with
my
husband,
Diego
Ingrosso,
a
clinical
biochemist.
I
was
fortunate
enough
to
be
able
to
contribute
with
a
chapter
on
homocysteine
to
the
Massry
Glassock’s
Textbook
of
Nephrology,
a
wonderful
and
informative
book
(Figure
1),
very
much
utilized,
along
with
the
Nutritional
Management
of
renal
disease
text.
I
still
cherish his dedication on the front page of my personal copy (Fig. 2).
Figure 2. Dedication.
Figure 1. The Massry Glassock’s Textbook of Nephrology.
Figure 3. Prof Massry, to his left prof Guido Bellinghieri,
to his right prof Toshimizu Niwa and his wife.
Guido Bellinghieri
Accademia Peloritana Pericolanti
Vincenzo Savica
Accademia Peloritana Pericolanti
SHAUL MASSRY IN SICILY
I
can't
find
the
words
to
express
the
great
pain
I
feel
in
my
heart
at
this
moment
for
the
passing
of
dear
Shaul,
whom
I
considered
as
my
second
father
(fig.1).
He
was
a
generous
man,
a
life
lover,
a
great
optimist.
In
the
long
telephone
conversations
we
often
had,
I
always
expressed
my
gratitude
to
him
for
everything
he
had
done
for
me,
having
radically
changed
the
course
of
my
life.
A
man
of
science,
endowed
with
great
humanity
and
charisma,
he
dedicated
his
entire
life
to
suffering
humanity
and
his
family.
Thanks
to
his
great
communication
skills
he
transmitted
the
fruits
of
his
research
to
hundreds
of
nephrologists
from
every
corner
of
the
earth,
who
had
the
good
fortune
to
drink
from
the
source
of
his
knowledge.
Anyone
who
was
lucky
enough
to
know
him
and
be
close
to
him
today
mourns
his
passing,
which
leaves
a
void
that
cannot
be
filled.
With
sincere
affection
we
express
our
deepest
condolences
to
all
the
family
members.
That
is
the
message
that
my
wife
Lilla,
my
son
Pietro
and
I
sent
to
Meira
and
Joel
Kopple
when
we
learned
of the death of our dear friend Shaul.
Vincenzo
Savica
and
I
were
lucky
enough
to
meet
Shaul
Massry
personally
during
a
scientific
congress
held
in
Bari
in
the
distant
1980s,
during
which
we
presented
the
results
of
a
research
on
the
carnitine
metabolism
in
uremic
patients.
At
the
end
of
my
presentation
during
the
discussion
he
intervened
expressing
his
appreciation
for
the
results
achieved
and
he
wanted
to
meet
us
through
our
common
friend
Natale
De
Santo
(fig.2).
During
the
conversation
he
expressed
his
great
interest
for
Sicily
and
invited
us
to
start
a
collaboration,
which
lasted
over
thirty
years
in
the
scientific-
organizational
field
with
the
aim
of
promoting
every
initiative
aimed
at
the
development
of
Sicilian
nephrology.
A
sincere
and
affectionate
friendship
was
born
from
that
moment,
as
evidenced
by
a
dedication
made
to
me
on
the
occasion
of
my
70th
birthday,
which
I
quote
verbatim:
“cast
thy
bread
upon
the
waters
for
thou
shalt
find
it
after
many
days,
Ecclesiates
chapter
XI,
verse
I,”
and
he
continues
“on
the
occasion
of
your
seventieth
birthday,
all
the
bread
that
you
have
been
casting
upon
the
waters
all
your
life,
is
coming
back
to
you
in
the
form
of
the
letters
from
your
friends
and
collegues
expressing
their
admiration
of
your
character
and
humanity,
their
appreciation
of
your
scientific
achievement
and
contribution
and
their
recognition
of
you
frienship
and
support.
God
bless
you
and
yours
for
now
and
forever and may he grant you wealth and prosperity for many years to come” . Meira and Shaul Massry .
From
1989
on,
numerous
scientific
initiatives
followed
under
his
guidance
through
the
Taormina
Course
on
Nephrology,
which,
during
the
first
edition
held
from
29
August
to
1
September
1990
(fig.3,4)
saw
the
most
prestigious
protagonists
of
international
nephrology
on
the
podium
such
as
R.L.Tannen,
D.G.
Warnock,
R.L.
W.D.
Boswell
Jr.,
S.Klahr,
G.Eknoyan,
W.E.Mitch,
R.M.Schaefer,
M.Mydlik
(fig.5,6),
A.Heidland;
national
nephrology
such
as
N.
De
Santo,
G.Piccoli,
V.Cambi,
N.Di
Paolo,
F.P.Schena,
G.Camussi,
A.Sessa,
G.Bazzato,
A.Borsatti,
F.Linari,
M.Timio,
G.A.Cinotti,
P.Coratelli,
G.Barsotti,
V.Bonomini,
A.Vercellone,
and
many
other
important
Sicilian
nephrologists
such
as:
C.Fede,
S.Baldari,
M.Li
Vecchi,
G.Daidone,
S.Gianni,
C.Todaro,C.Spata, A. Marrocco,D.Santoro, A.Liardo, V.Savica.
Another
nine
editions
of
the
Taormina
Course
of
Nephrology
were
subsequently
held
at
the
Grand
Hotel
S.Domenico
in
Taormina
every
two
years
involving
the
main
nephrological
scientific
fields
with
the
participation
of
the
major
representatives
of
nephrology
from
all
over
the
world
from
Australia
to
Japan,
from
the
numerous
countries
of
Eastern
Europe
(Poland,
Bulgaria,
Romania,
Czech
Republic,
Slovakia,
Hungary)
and
the
Middle
East
(Turkey,
Israel)
and
North Africa (Egypt, Tunisia, Morocco, Libya).
He
was
also
responsible
for
the
introduction
of
the
Malpighi
Gold
Medal(fig.7,8)
and
he
recorded
the
most
prestigious
representatives
of
the
nephrological
scientific
world
as
winners.
Just
to
name
a
few:
Shaul
Massry,
A.Vercellone,
G.E.
Striker,
V.Bonomini,
R.Mendez,
V.Andreucci,
K.Kurokawa,
N.G.
De
Santo, J.D.Kopple, W.F.Keane, W.E.Mitch, H.Morii, A.Dal Canton, G.Eknoyan, G.Piccoli.
His
contribution
was
also
invaluable
during
other
important
scientific
conferences,
organized
with
dear
colleague
Natale
De
Santo,
such
as
the
3rd
congress
of
the
International
Association
for
the
History
of
Nephrology
(IAHN)
in
2001
and
the
6th
congress
held
in
2008(fig.9,10,11)
and
the
1st
congress
of
the
Mediterranean
Kidney
Society.
Together
with
Joel
Kopple,
he
contributed
to
the
success
of
the
7th
Annual
Conference
of
the
International
Federation
of
the
Kidney
Foundation
held
in
Taormina
in
2006.
For
his
merits
acquired
in
the
scientific
field
and
for
his
contributions
given
to
the
development
of
Sicilian
Nephrology,
in
October
2000
Shaul
Massry
as
awarded
an
honorary
degree
the
“Laurea
Honoris
Causa
in
Medicine”
from
the
Rector
of
the
University
of
Messina Prof. Gaetano Silvestri, who was subsequently elected President of the Italian Constitutional Court.
For
his
constant
and
passionate
interest
in
Sicilian
nephrological
problems
he
earned
the
esteem
of
all
Sicilian
nephrologists,
who
saw
him
as
the
noble
father
of
Sicilian
scientific
development
with
his
positive
effects
on
the
health
of
tens
of
thousands
of
Sicilian
patients,
affected
by
kidney
disease,
undergoing
dialysis
and
transplants,
who
today
saddened
thank
the
man
of
science,
who
came
from
afar,
to
alleviate
their
indescribable
suffering.
There
is
no
doubt
all
that
is
the
result
of
his
innate
generosity
of
soul,
his
strong
scientific
personality
and
his
fervent
intellectual
activity.
Above
all
he
had
a
formidable
fiber,
he
was
a
true
gentleman,
whose
contact
instantly
developed
human
warmth
and
a
sincere
friendship
worth
gold.
In
addition
to
being
a
great
nephrologist,
Massry
was
also
a
great
professor
of
medicine,
endowed
not
only
with
gigantic
generosity,
but
also
with
enormous
humanity
and
a
lover
of
the
precious
value
of
life.
His
motto
was
"Guido
smile
at
life
and
life
will
smile
at
you",
and
he
always
used
to
say
at
the
end
of
problematic
speeches
that,
whatever
happens,
“Life
is
Beautiful".
In
memory
of
a
great,
affectionate,
paternal
friendship
which
binds
me
to
the
Man
Shaul
Massry,
I
say
that
his
figure
will
remain
everlasting
in
the
hearts
and
minds
of
those
who,
like
Vincenzo,
Natale
and
I,
had
the
great
fortune
to
meet
him
in
this
short
earthly
life
and to enjoy the fruits of his prolific intellect. In conclusion I must confess that a sincere, warm and spontaneous tear is running down my face.
Davide Viggiano
Department of Translational
Medical Sciences,
Univ. of Campania “L. Vanvitelli”,
Naples, Italy
ON THE SCIENTIFIC NETWORK OF PROF SHAUL MASSRY
Prof
Shaul
Massry,
Emeritus
of
Medicine,
Physiology,
and
Biophysics
at
the
University
of
Southern
California
was
undoubtedly what is called, in Network theory, a "hub". Let me explain why this is so important.
The
network
theory
describes
any
system
composed
of
discrete
objects
(or
“nodes”)
which
interact
through
connections
(denoted
as
“edges”).
Among
the
various
applications,
the
one
concerning
the
scientific
society
is
of
interest
here,
where
nodes
are
scientists,
and
edges
are
the
connections
among
them,
usually
in
the
form
of
a
co-
authorship in a paper. People with a large number of connections are called a "hub".
Shaul
Massry,
with
his
466
publications
on
Pubmed
and
the
large
number
of
students
formed
under
his
direction,
was
undoubtedly
a
"hub".
I
have
reported
in
Figure
1
the
network
around
prof
Massry,
as
can
be
derived
from
the
publications
in
Pubmed.
The
network
has
been
obtained
with
the
software
VOSviewer.
This
software
shows
larger
circles
when
more
than
one
publication
links
Massry
and
another
author.
For
graphic
limitations
not
all
Massry’s
coauthors are readable.
Figure 1. The network of authorships of prof Massry,
as generated by the software VOSviewer
Now,
in
network
theory,
we
speak
of
the
“small
world
phenomenon”
when
two
any
nodes
of
a
network
are
connected
by
a
minimal
number
of
edges.
This
phenomenon
was
described
in
a
famous
experiment
by
psychologist
Stanley
Milgram
in
1967.
The
"small
world"
phenomenon
is
due
to
the
presence
of
hubs
in
the
network,
that
is,
of
people
with
a
great
number
of
connections.
The
hubs
allow
two
people
in
the
network
to
stay
connected
through
a
small
number of nodes, even though they do not know each other.
This
happens,
for
example,
in
the
scientific
network
of
mathematicians,
where
it
has
been
introduced
the
“Erdős
number”,
that
is
the
distance
(in
terms
of
co-autorship) of any mathematician from the prolific mathematician Paul Erdős, who was a “hub” in the network of mathematicians.
Scientists
like
Massry,
with
a
large
number
of
links,
have
made
our
Association
far
more
connected
than
otherwise.
Following
the
example
of
the
mathematicians,
I
have
a
"distance"
of
2
from
prof
Massry
(I
have
co-authored
a
paper
with
prof
De
Santo,
who
has
co-authored
a
paper
with
prof
Massry),
and thank to prof Massry I have a distance of 4 from Donald Seldin.
Prof
Massry
has
been
important
for
our
International
Association
of
History
of
Nephrology:
his
presence
in
the
association
contributed
to
make
the
meetings
so
successful,
together
with
several
giants
in
Nephrology
such
as
(the
list
is
not
meant
to
represent
all
great
nephrologists
in
our
society)
Steve
Peitzman,
Carl
Gottschalk,
Gerhardt
Giebisch,
Donald
Seldin,
Marc
DeBroe,
Stewart
Cameron,
George
Schreiner,
Garabed
Ecknoyan,
Spyros
Marketos,
Natale
De
Santo, just to name a few.
The
entire
publication
network
of
all
IAHN
members
(past
and
present)
is
extremely
large:
more
than
10000
publications
on
Pubmed.
This
network
is
too
big to be represented with all names and connections.
However,
I
have
tried
to
represent
(Fig.
2)
a
smaller
network
connecting
prof
Massry
with
some
of
the
nephrologists
in
our
society;
the
software,
in
some
cases, automatically clustered IAHN members from the same nationality authors.
Figure 2. Some of the network relationships between Shaul Massry and members of
the IAHN in terms of publication co-authorships. The network is incomplete, and
only a few nations are represented here due to graphical limitations.
Joel D. Kopple, MD
Professor Emeritus of Medicine
and Public Health, UCLA,
The Division of Nephrology and Hypertension
and The Lundquist Institute
at Harbor-UCLA Medical
Center, Los Angeles and Torrance, California
SHAUL MASSRY AND THE NATIONAL KIDNEY FOUNDATION, USA
Shaul
Massry,
MD
exerted
a
valuable
and
lasting
influence
on
the
National
Kidney
Foundation,
USA
(NKF).
Initially,
he
was
heavily
involved
with
the
local
Affiliate
of
the
NKF,
the
National
Kidney
Foundation
of
Southern
California
(NKFSC).
In
addition
to
chairing
one
of
its
annual
symposia
and
chairing
its
research
committee,
Dr.
Massry
headed
its
Scientific
Advisory
Council
(i.e.,
Medical
Advisory
Board)
from
1974
to
1976.
Both
before
and
during
the
time
that
he
was
chair
of
the
Division
of
Nephrology
at
the
University
of
Southern
California
(USC)
School
of
Medicine
and
the
Los
Angeles
County
USC
Medical
Center,
Dr.
Massry
and
many
of
his
fellows
and
assistants
competed
for
and
were
awarded
many
competitive
research
grants
from
the
NKFSC.
These
research
grants
contributed
to
the
enormously
creative and productive research output that Dr. Massry displayed over so many years (1).
As
Dr.
Massry’s
national
and
international
stature
as
a
physician,
scientist
and
academician
grew,
he
became
very
involved
in
the
NKF
at
the
national
level.
Among
his
official
positions
in
the
NKF,
Dr.
Massry
served
on
the
Scientific
Advisory
Board
(SAB)
from
1974
to
1979,
was
a
member
of
the
Executive
Committee
of
the
SAB
of
the
NKF
from
1977
to
1980,
was
co-chair
of
the
NKF
Scientific
Program
Committee
in
1985-1986,
was
chair
of
this
same
committee
in
1987
and
1988,
was
Region
V
President
of
the
NKF
in
1988,
was
chair
of
the
National
Medical
Advisory
Board
(formerly
called
the
Scientific
Advisory
Board)
of
the
NKF
in
1989-1990,
and
served
as
Vice-President
of
the
NKF in 1989-1990 and President of the NKF in 1990-1992.
Dr.
Massry’s
contributions
to
the
NKFSC
and
NKF
were
characterized
by
his
typical
affability,
strong
leadership
qualities
and
vision.
As
Vice-President
and
President
of
the
NKF,
Dr.
Massry
took
it
upon
himself
to
raise
money
for
the
recently
established
NKF
research
endowment
fund.
Dr.
Massry
personally
raised
more
money
for
the
NKF
research endowment fund than any other individual.
As
NKF
President,
Dr.
Massry
established
the
NKF
International
Prize.
This
highly
coveted
prize
is
given
to
distinguished
professionals
from
outside
the
United
States
who
have
made
meritorious
contributions
to
the
science
of
nephrology
or
the
treatment
of
kidney
disease.
The
recipients
of
the
NKF
International
Prize
are
commonly
distinguished
professors
of
nephrology
in
other
countries.
Establishing
this
prize
was
consistent
with
Dr.
Massry’s
vision
that
advances
in
the
broad
fields
of
the
science
and
treatment
of
nephrological
problems
are
and
should
be
an
international effort (1).
Guido Gembillo
1,2
;
Guido Bellinghieri
1
;
Salvatore Silipigni
2
;
Luigi Peritore
1
;
Vincenzo Savica
2
and Domenico Santoro
1
1
University of Messina, Unit of Nephrology
and Dialysis, Department of Clinical and
Experimental Medicine, Messina, Italy.
2
University of Messina, Department
of Biomedical, Dental, Morphological and
Functional Imaging Sciences, Messina, Italy.
3
A. Monroy Institute of Biomedicine
and Molecular Immunology,
National Research Council, Palermo, Italy.
100 YEARS OF UROGRAPHY - FROM THE BEGINNINGS TO MRI
Radiological
imaging
of
the
urinary
tract
has
made
advances
in
the
21st
century
that
no
one
would
have
thought
of
at
the
time
of
its
first
presentation.
The
first
urograms
were
performed
in
the
early
years
of
the
20th
century
by
retrograde
catheterisation
of
the
ureters.
But
a
major
acceleration
of
the
technique
came
with
the
invention
of
excretory
urography
(i.e. the intravenous urogram).
The
invention
of
this
technique
has
spurred
the
development
of
contrast
agents
that
utilise
the
excretion
of
organic
iodine molecules in the urine.
It
is
important
to
underline
the
evolution
that
urinary
tract
imaging
has
undergone
over
the
last
century
and
celebrate
the first century since the invention of intravenous urography.
The
first
radiological
techniques
to
study
the
urinary
tract
involved
invasive
catheterisation
of
the
ureters
and
did
not
provide
a
complete
view
of
the
urinary
tract
as
there
was
no
means
of
assessing
the
function
of
the
renal
parenchyma.
The
invention
of
intravenous
urography
represented
a
revolution
that
made
it
possible
not
only
to
visualise
the
urinary
system with great anatomical precision, but also to assess conditions affecting the renal parenchyma.
Using
the
same
technique,
the
use
of
iodine
radioisotopes
opened
the
way
to
modern
renal
scintigraphy,
which
has
since been a powerful tool for assessing renal function.
With
the
advent
of
computed
tomography
(CT)
in
diagnostic
imaging,
the
diagnostic
challenges
with
the
advantage
of
determining the density of urinary stones in the urinary tract became more advanced.
With
the
advent
of
modern
multidetector
devices
(
CT
),
which
allow
rapid
multiphase
volumetric
assessment
of
the
urinary
tract
with
the
possibility
of
multiplanar
reformatting
of
images,
all
the
advantages
of
CT
have
been
progressively perfected and many pitfalls overcome.
The
severe
limitation
of
CT
imaging
is
outweighed
by
the
considerable
radiation
dose
and
renal
toxicity
from
the
contrast
agent.
In
addition,
relative
and
absolute
contraindications
limit
the
use
of
CT
urography
in
younger
patients
and pregnant women.
In
recent
decades,
the
radiation
dose
and
contrast
agent
volume
have
been
reduced
by
the
introduction
of
dual
energy
CT
(DECT)
scanners,
which
are
also
used
for
spectral
assessment
of
the
atomic
number
of
kidney
stones
and
characterise the mineral composition of the stones.
The
final
step
in
urological
imaging
has
been
achieved
with
the
development
of
modern
MRI
scanners
that
allow
radiation-free
urography
with
intravenous
gadolinium
contrast
agent
(MR
urography)
and
can
also
image
a
stationary
fluid in the excretory organs without injection of contrast agent (MR pyelography).
Imaging
of
the
urinary
tract
has
made
remarkable
progress
in
the
last
century
thanks
to
advances
in
technology.
The
progress
made
since
the
first
attempts
with
exponential
growth
and
the
continuous
tendency
to
improve
suggest
that
the end point of this process is still far away.
Figure 2. V.Savica, S.G.Massry, N.G.De Santo,
F.Consolo, G.Bellinghieri
Figure 1. Shaul Massry and Guido Bellinghieri
Figure 4. 1st Taormina Course S.Domenico Hotel:
Open ceremony(1990)
Figure 3. Taormina Course on Nephrology
and Malpighi Gold Medal
Figure 6. M.Mydlik and K.Derzsiovà
Figure 5. First edition of Taormina Course:
international speakers
Figure 8. H. Morii, Winner of Malpighi Gold Medal,
and his Wife
Figure 7. Shaul Massry receives the First Malpighi Gold Medal
Figure 9. Rutkowski,Bellinghieri,Massry and Kurtzman:
Meeting on Uremia Research
Figure 11. Taormina: the Council of IAHN 2008
(Smogorzweski, Eknoyan, Calò,
De Santo, Bellinghieri,Massry,
Opatrna, Touwaide,Diamandopoulos
Figure 10. Messina University : first line from left: G.Bellinghieri,
J. Kopple, Shaul andMeira Massry, Rector Tomasello,
dean of Internal Medicine F.Consolo
Figure 1. Professor Shaul Massry.
Shaul Massry a man of giving
Shaul
Massry
was
generous.
This
is
attested
by
the
huge
number
of
fellows.
However,
one
could
best
appreciate
this
attitude
during
the
morning
rounds,
and
by
the
“intensity”
of
his
participation
during
the
hours
spent
in
rewriting
the
papers
of
the
colleagues
before
publication.
He
had
spent
his
first
years
as
a
young
doctor
in
the
communities
living
around
the
dead
sea,
an
unappealing
place.
He
went
and
did
even
seminal
investigation.
He
was
very
delighted
and
thankful
to
De
Santo
when
he
first
showed
him
the
book
of
Goubout
and
Caille
on
the
meaning
of
the
gift
(6).
In
that
book
one
learns
that
the
Lake
of
Tiberias
(Sea
of
Galilee)
is
the
lake
of
generosity,
of
the
great
exchanges,
rich
in
tributaries
and
emissaries
that
make
its
shores
green
(6).
It
is
a
lake
that
takes
and
gives,
a
lake
generating
the
exchange,
there
is
life
on
its
shores
and
in
its
waters
that
quench
the
thirst
of
the
inhabitants
of
Jerusalem.
In
its
water
lived
fishes
that
were
multiplied
by
Jesus.
It
is
unlike
the
Dead
Sea
that
is
the
egoistic
sea
that
takes
all
the
waters
left
from
Jordan
and
on
its
shores
there
is
no
life
(7).
“There
is
a
kind
of
social
law
that
causes
death
of
what
does
not
circulate”.
Although
originating
from
the
same
river
–
the
Jordan
–
the
lake
of
Tiberias
is
a
lake
of
life,
the
other
is
the
sea
of
death.
The
first
gives
water
to
other
rivers,
exchanges
its
water
with
them,
the
second
takes
the
remaining
waters of the Jordan (6). Shaul, who worked for the communities on the Dead Sea, was a benevolent man, he can be associated with the Lake of Tiberias.
Conclusion
Our
friend
has
gone.
As
Garabed
Eknoyan
stresses
in
this
issue
the
Bulletin,
we
had
a
motto
together:
“Life
is
beautiful
and
friends
are
it
perfume’s.
Friendship
among
scientists
―
the
most
competitive
persons
of
our
world―
is
a
divine
grace
but
also
a
personal
achievement
made
of
respect,
reason
and
goodwill.
Massry,
our
friend,
as
university
professor
affected
the
lives
of
his
fellows.
In
this
–
as
Carlo
Rovelli,
a
quantum
physicist,
says
in
a
recent
book―he
was
“a cause, and his intervention left a trace. A memory: its effect” (8).
References
1. Calvino I. Perché leggere i classici. Milan, Oscar Mondadori 1991.
2. Eknoyan G, De Santo NG, Massry S.G. On the future of the History of Nephrology. Am J Nephrol 1994; 14: 355-6.
3. Steiner G. My unwritten books. New York, New Directions. 2007.
4.
De
Santo
NG,
Eknoyan
G
(Eds),
Capasso
Gm
Marotta
P
(Co-eds).
Human
Clinical
Reserch.
Ethics
and
Economics.
Naples,
Istituto
Italianao
per
gli
Studi
Filosofiic, 19971, 19982.
5.
De
Santo
NG.
De
santo
RM.
Avvocato
Gerardo
Marotta
(Naples
April
26,1927
–
January
25,
2017):
in
memoriam.G
ItalNefrol
2018;
35
(Supplement
70,
Proceedings10th IAHN Congress) – ISSN 1724-5990 – © 2018 Società Italiana di Nefrologia
6. Godbout JT, Caille A. L’esprit du don. La Découverte, Paris,1996.
7.
De
Rosa
G.
La
donazione
degli
organi,
un
percorso
significativo
di
formazione
alla
solidarietà
ed
alla
responsabilità
nella
scuola
del
primo
ciclo.Un’esperienzapersonale. Thesis at the Pegaso University, Naples, Academical year 2015-2016, p. 72.
8. Rovelli C. I Buchi bianchi. Dentro l’orizzonte. Milano: Adelphi, 2023, pp. 119-120.
Figure 2. International Conference on History of Nephrology
in Naples-Montecassino, Italy.
Figure 1. International Conference on History of Nephrology
in Naples-Montecassino, Italy.
Figure 4. International Conference on the History of Nephrology:
Exibition of diuretic plants described by Dioscorides
in the Abbey of Montecassino, Italy.
Figure 3. International Conference on the History of Nephreology.
Latin Catologue of Codices in the Montecassino Archives, Italy.
Figure 6. 7th European Colloquium on Renal Physiology in 1997 in Naples.
Excursion to the Temples of Paestum, Italy.
Figure 5. Rafting on the waters of the River Dunajec
in Tatras Mountains in 1996, Slovakia
Figure 8. 20 Years of Nephrology in Cassino. Scientific events
in the Sala Capitularis of the Abbey of Montecassino, Italy.
Figure 7. 20 Years of Nephrology in Cassino. Scientific
events in the Sala Capitularis of the Abbey of Montecassino, Italy.
Figure 10. Meeting on Uremic Toxins: Nagoya, 1999, Japan
Figure 9. 20 Years of Nephrology in Cassino. Scientific events in the Sala
Capitularis of the Abbey of Montecassino, Italy.
Figure 11. Meeting on Uremic Toxins:Gdansk 2005, Poland.
Another of Dr. Massry’s seminal contributions to the NKF and, by extension, to American and international nephrology was initiating the change in the
dates of the annual NKF clinical nephrology meetings. At the time that Dr. Massry assumed the presidency of the NKF, the NKF annual clinical meetings
had been held for many years in the autumn, immediately adjacent to the annual nephrology meeting of the American Society of Nephrology (ASN).
During this time, the ASN had grown into a highly prominent and influential scientific and professional society. The ASN leadership wanted to expand its
annual nephrology meeting from a 2-3 day event to a longer and more extensive activity. Among other goals, the ASN wanted to greatly expand the clinical
component of its annual meeting. The fact that the NKF clinical meeting occurred next to the ASN meeting provided a major impediment to these plans.
This led to some conflict of opinion between the leaderships of the ASN and the NKF. Dr. Massry was among the first to perceive that this matter could only
be resolved if the NKF chronologically disassociated its annual clinical meeting from the annual meeting of the ASN.
Dr. Massry therefore proposed to move the annual NKF clinical meeting to the spring. This proposal initially met with some stiff opposition within the
NKF leadership which Dr. Massry overcame. This new annual meeting came to be called the National Kidney Foundation Spring Clinical Meetings, and
these meetings have evolved into the major scientific and professional events that they are today. The NKF Spring Clinical Meetings are not only a major
scientific, professional and educational activity in nephrology for physicians, but also for nurses, social workers and dietitians. These meetings have also
become the venue for a major annual NKF business meeting, for the annual issuing of awards by the NKF, and for general fund raising and business
activities of the NKF. Credit must be given to Dr. Massry because it was his vision, insight and leadership abilities that set the groundwork for all of this to
happen. The ASN, in turn, turned their annual meeting into the well-known annual ASN Kidney Week.
The foregoing contributions by Dr. Massry to the NKFSC and the NKF exemplify the extraordinary grasp of basic and clinical science in nephrology, the
national and international vision, and the highly effective leadership of Dr. Massry (1). Dr. Massry’s ability to successfully lead the NKF was due in no
small part to his ability to connect deeply with people from all walks of life, to communicate to them his vision as to how to improve the world, and to bond
with and inspire strong loyalties among his colleagues and coworkers.
Citations
1.
Joel D. Kopple, MD, Mirek Smogorzewski, MD and Garabed Eknoyan In Memoriam: Shaul G. Massry, MD (1930 – 2023) Kidney International
2023, In Press
INFO FROM POLAND
Professor
Shaul
Massry’s
death
caused
bitter
grief
among
Polish
nephrologists,
many
of
whom
were
close
friends
with
the
great
colleague.
S.
Massry
visited
Poland
on
numerous
occasions
and
many
Polish
doctors
trained
at
his
centre
in
the
USA.
I
will
be
privileged
to
give
a
lecture
titled
“Shaul
Massry
and
his
Input
in
the
Development
of
Nephrology
in
Central-Eastern
Europe”
during
the
23rd
Katowice
Seminar
“Progress
in
Nephrology
and
Hypertension”
in
November
this
year.
The
December
issue
of
the
IAHN
Bulletin
will
contain
an
account
of
this
crucial
scientific
event
along
with
more
information
concerning
Shaul
Massry’s
connections
with
Poland.
One
should
not
forget
that
he
was
an
honorary
member of the Polish Society of Nephrology.
Over the first six months of this year Polish members of the IAHN attended the following scientific conferences.
In
January
this
year,
the
19th
Gdańsk
Nephrology
Recapitulatory
Meeting
-
Post
ASN
Meeting
took
place.
This
annual
event,
organised
by
prof.
Bolesław
Rutkowski,
aims
to
provide
new
information
after
the
Congress
of
the
American
Society
of
Nephrology
(Fig.
1).
During
the
two-day
seminar,
the
long
list
of
speakers
included:
prof.
Andrzej
Więcek,
an
honorary
member
of
the
IAHN
("Hypertension
as
an
Immune-Mediated
Disease"),
prof.
Przemysław
Rutkowski
("Artificial
Intelligence
in
the
Assessment
of
Kidney
Biopsies")
and
Janusz
Ostrowski
("Women in nephrology") (Fig. 2).
Figure 2. Professor Janusz Ostrowski
(Photo: Maria Ostrowska)
Figure 1. Professor Boleslaw Rutkowski, the main organiser.
(Photo: Janusz Ostrowski)
Figure 1. Prof. Janusz Ostrowski, first right
(Photo: Maria Ostrowska)
Figure 2. Professor Bolesław Rutkowski
(Photo: Janusz Ostrowski)
Figure 1. Professor Andrzej Więcek
(Photo: Janusz Ostrowski)
Figure 3. Professor Janusz Ostrowski, first left, and Professor Ryszard Gellert
(photo: Maria Ostrowska)
Figure 2. From right: Prof. Janusz Ostrowski,
Prof. Bolesław Rutkowski
Figure 1. Professor Janusz Ostrowski
(photo Maria Ostrowska)
Janusz Ostrowski
Professor,
Centre of Postgraduate
Medical Education,
Warsaw, Poland